
Statement: House Votes to Expand Warrantless Surveillance
April 12, 2024
Newsletter: May 2024
May 1, 2024Letter to Columbia President Minouche Shafik: Political expression concerns on campus
2024 pro-Palestine protests at Columbia University
April 22, 2024
Dear President Shafik,
Defending Rights & Dissent is a national civil liberties organization dedicated to protecting the right of political expression. We are deeply concerned about recent actions you have taken that jeopardize the rights of political expression at Columbia University.
We recognize that Columbia is a private institution and thus not bound by the US Constitution. Yet, several of your recent actions have such a strong nexus to threats to the First Amendment we feel compelled to weigh in. This includes:
- your testimony before a US Congressional hearing about the political speech of Columbia University students and faculty,
- your decision to notify the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) about your students’ political speech,
- your decision to have the New York Police Department (NYPD) arrest nonviolent protesters.
Our organization traces its founding back to the National Committee to Abolish the House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC). Two of our founders were jailed for their refusal to testify before HUAC. While the McCarthy-era had heroes who defended the First Amendment by defying the HUAC inquisition, there were also many cowards who conformed with HUAC’s dictates.
It was impossible not to recall the legacy of HUAC during the April 17, 2024, hearing of the House of Representatives’ Education and the Workforce Committee. The committee clearly aimed to punish individuals for their exercise of First Amendment-speech and purge America’s universities of political perspectives the committee members disfavored. Disturbingly, this was presented as an inquiry into rising anti-Semitism. Anti-Semitism is a deplorable form of bigotry responsible for some of history’s greatest crimes. Yet, the hearing was not rooted in good faith concern with anti-Semitism. It was a transparent attempt to target pro-Palestine speech.
During the hearing, you were asked about the political views of specific professors and encouraged to take disciplinary action, including termination, against them. Such clear retaliation for First-Amendment protected speech would be prohibited at a state institution. Although Columbia University is a private institution not governed by the First Amendment, the role of state actors – in this case members of Congress – in instigating the action would raise serious First Amendment concerns. Even if the First Amendment could not be found to apply, it would still be a serious breach of norms of academic freedom.
Such a flagrant attack on academic freedom requires a firm rebuttal. Yet, instead you appeared to appease the committee.
During your testimony, you told the Committee no less than four times about how you reported a student event to the FBI. According to your testimony, students repeatedly asked for school approval to host an event called “Resistance 101.” The school repeatedly denied approval, at which point the student “decamped to a dorm room and held it online.” When you learned the event, which consisted solely of First Amendment protected speech, nevertheless occurred, you stated, “We immediately, as soon as we knew, notified the FBI.”
While we recognize that many people disagreed with the political content of the event, it is shocking for a college administrator to report students to the FBI for political speech. Under our Constitution, it is impermissible for law enforcement or intelligence agencies to monitor or take action against political speech. This is true even if that speech is controversial or some individuals find it offensive. The FBI has a long history of illegally surveilling and seeking to silence political speech. We would know, as our organization was subjected to illegal FBI surveillance and harassment. The FBI not only has a history of harassment of social movements, it has a particularly vicious history of targeting pro-Palestine speech. This makes your actions all the more dangerous.
Finally, as you are aware, student protesters calling on the university to divest from companies complicit in the violation of Palestinian human rights have been holding a peaceful protest. These students have been the subject of a massive onslaught of demonization, with local and national politicians, and even a foreign government, falsely equating their actions with terrorism and calling for state repression. On April 18, you invited the NYPD onto your private campus to arrest your own students engaged in nonviolent protest. The NYPD has a reputation for use of excessive force against peaceful protests, as evidenced by its conduct during the Occupy Wall Street and George Floyd protests. Given the purely peaceful nature of the encampment, it is a dramatic escalation to invite the NYPD to arrest the students.
In spite of the NYPD’s track record of hostility towards protests, NYPD Chief John Cells directly contradicted your depiction of the events. In an email to the campus you justified your actions by stating the students were “a clear and present danger.” Yet according to Cells, “the students that were arrested were peaceful, offered no resistance whatsoever, and were saying what they wanted to say in a peaceful manner.”
We are deeply disturbed by all of the aforementioned incidents, all of which seem to be the direct result of your actions. While it is rare for us to comment on a private institution’s actions, all of these incidents are closely entwined with state attacks on First Amendment rights, mandating us to weigh-in.
We ask you to take the following steps to address these concerns:
- All administrators must be trained in First Amendment law, so that they can understand what constitutes core protected political speech. Additionally, administrators should be required to learn the history of McCarthyism and its impact on the US academic community;
- Issue a clear statement to the Education and the Workforce Committee that no professor or student will be disciplined for political speech and rebuking the Committee’s abuse of their own power to try to coerce the university into punishing individuals for exercising their First Amendment rights;
- Launch a transparent investigation of the decision to report students to the FBI for First Amendment protected conduct and undertake meaningful disciplinary action against any Columbia administrator found to have acted improperly;
- Conduct a transparent investigation of the decision to issue false statements about the student protest and to call in the NYPD and impose meaningful disciplinary action against any Columbia administrator found to have acted improperly;
- Allow the suspended students to return to campus to complete the academic year;
- Allow the peaceful encampment to continue without threat of bringing the NYPD on campus;
- Publicly defend the rights of your students and faculty to engage in political speech on any issue and push back on the narrative that student and faculty speech in support of Palestinian rights constitutes “terrorism” or “anti-Semitism.”
We look forward to hearing from you on this matter.




