Silver Spring Justice Coalition Demands Answers After Unjustified Arrest of Neighborhood “Good Samaritan,” Samir Ahmed. Yes, He is Black.

DRAD Defends Human Rights Defenders
December 10, 2018
US Capitol at Night
Another Assault on The Right to Boycott by the Lame Duck Congress
December 12, 2018

The Silver Spring Justice Coalition was born earlier this year to protest the unjustified killing of an unarmed Black man by a Montgomery County Police Officer. Residents of the city and county consider their community to be an oasis of progressivism and tolerance. The lack of accountability for the officer, or recognition that the police force acts the way police do everywhere and therefore serious reforms are needed, has compelled the Coalition to remain together to fight for necessary changes.

Defending Rights & Dissent is a member of the coalition, which includes many grassroots organizations and individuals. In a community-driven process, the group is defining its mission and goals. All in the community are invited to participate (reach out to to get involved).

In November, police again disgraced themselves by treating another Black man with undue aggression, arresting Samir Ahmed in his own neighborhood after he had helped an intoxicated neighbor home. The video of Mr. Ahmed’s arrest went viral. The Silver Spring Justice Coalition has sent a letter to the County Executive, Police Chief, and the State’s Attorney for Montgomery County. The letter is below.

County Executive Marc Elrich
Montgomery County Executive Office Building
101 Monroe Street
Rockville, MD 20850

Chief Thomas Manger
Montgomery County Police Department
100 Edison Park Drive, 3rd floor
Gaithersburg, MD 20878

John McCarthy
Office of the State’s Attorney for Montgomery County
50 Maryland Avenue, 5th floor, Judicial Center
Rockville, MD 20850

Dear Mr. Elrich, Chief Manger, and Mr. McCarthy,

We, the members of the Silver Spring Justice Coalition, are concerned about the recent arrest of Samir Ahmed on November 17, 2018.  We request a meeting with County Executive Elrich and State’s Attorney McCarthy. According to numerous news reports, someone in the Silver Spring neighborhood called emergency services to check on the welfare of a resident who appeared intoxicated, however, when Montgomery County police officers arrived, they apprehended Mr. Ahmed, placed him in handcuffs, and held him, face down, over a squad car.

In a video clip of the arrest which has gone viral (The Washington Post, The Huffington Post, WUSA9, WTOP, Atlanta Black Star, New York Post), neighbors can be heard yelling “he lives here,” “he’s not who we were calling about,” “actually he was helping the person under the influence,” “you’re not helping the person who needs the help, the person is unconscious on the floor, why aren’t you helping the person we called for you to arrest?”

Neighbors also asked, “what is he under arrest for?” to which one of your officers replied, “we don’t answer to you.”  Your officer then said, “stop resisting” and neighbors can be heard saying “he’s not resisting.” Neighbors repeatedly asked officers to provide their names and the officers did not provide their names, other than the one officer who stopped to show her name on her uniform. It is unclear why Mr. Ahmed was arrested given neighbors quickly explained to police they had the wrong man, and that Mr. Ahmed was helping a neighbor who may have been intoxicated and incapacitated.

In addition, a check of the local court dockets showed Mr. Ahmed has been charged with disorderly conduct, resisting arrest, failure to obey a lawful order and obstruction and hindering.  Given the publicly available video of the arrest, members of the Silver Spring Justice coalition are concerned that these charges represent over-policing of minorities, and inability to admit error on the part of MCPD.  The collateral consequences of these charges should not be taken lightly. Mr. Ahmed’s employment, ability to earn wages, and future employment prospects could be considerably impacted by these charges. Also, the taxpayers should not foot the bill for court costs, MCPD costs, and any public defense costs, for charges that should not have been filed.

These charges call into question the veracity of similar charges in incidents that are not caught on video, harming the credibility of the police. In its investigation of the Ferguson Police Department, the Department of Justice found officers often stopped people without reasonable suspicion, made arrests without probable cause, and relied heavily on “failure to comply” charges in its practices.

MCPD is not immune to racial bias in its police practices.  This summer, Robert White, a black man with mental disability, was killed in an altercation with a police officer.  The officer’s reason for initially stopping Mr. White, a rip in his shirt, does not dissuade the community that racial bias was not involved.

During the listening sessions with Marc Elrich and Montgomery County residents, County Executive Elrich indicated more training was needed to address these two incidents. However, training without accountability is not sufficient.  Further, any training model adopted by MCPD should include community input.

We reject the police officer’s assertion that MCPD does not answer to the public.  We, the citizens of Montgomery County, deserve a police force with officers who understand, that they do, indeed, answer to and serve the public, and a police force where we can trust the integrity in an officer’s decision to detain and arrest.

We would appreciate a timely response to our concerns in this matter.


Silver Spring Justice Coalition, including:

ACLU of Maryland, Montgomery County Chapter

Defending Rights and Dissent

Jews United for Justice

Maryland Alliance for Court Reform

Montgomery County Civil Rights Coalition

MoCo Pride Center

Muslim Public Affairs Council

Showing Up for Racial Justice-Montgomery County, MD

Sisterhood of Salam/Shalom, Silver Spring-Takoma Park chapter

Takoma Park Mobilization-Ending Mass Incarceration